The Federal Communications Commission of the United States (the FCC or the Commission) released on Thursday 31 October 2024 a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, Review of Submarine Cable Landing License Rules and Procedures to Assess Evolving National Security, Law Enforcement, Foreign Policy, and Trade Policy Risks, Dkts. No. 24-523 and 24-524 (Oct. 31, 2024).

The proposed rulemaking would launch the FCC’s first major comprehensive review of its undersea cable rules since 2001, would propose to codify its legal jurisdiction, improve oversight, and take several actions to protect the infrastructure from national security, law enforcement, and other risks.

FCC Chair Jessica Rosenworcel said “over the past two decades, the technology, economics, and security challenges involving these systems have greatly changed, but FCC oversight has not.”

Rosenworcel added the FCC would vote on Nov. 21 to undertake the first major comprehensive review of its submarine cable rules since 2001. The FCC is considering updates to its rules to address the national security impacts of undersea cables that handle more than 95% of international internet traffic.

The proposed rulemaking would

  • propose to codify the Commission’s legal jurisdiction and other legal requirements in its rules to provide regulatory certainty to submarine cable owners and operators, including
    • (1) when a submarine cable license is required under the Cable Landing License Act;
    • (2) an appropriate definition of a submarine cable system;
    • (3) the existing public interest standard;
    • (4) the character qualification requirements; and
    • (5) a process to withhold or revoke a cable landing license.
  • Propose a three-year periodic review process for cable landing licenses and seeks comment on shortening the current 25-year license term (or in combination with periodic reporting) to improve the Commission’s oversight of submarine cable licensees.
  • Seek comment on updating application requirements for national security purposes and to ensure the Commission has targeted and granular information regarding the ownership, control, and use of a submarine cable system.
    • The FCC would seek comment on modernizing our existing application rules to better identify and capture information on those entities that own and control the submarine cable system and connect with terrestrial networks in the United States.
    • The FCC proposed to adopt a presumption that any entity whose application for international section 214 authority that was previously denied or whose domestic or international section 214 authority was previously revoked in view of national security and law enforcement concerns, and its current and future affiliates and subsidiaries, shall not be qualified to become a new submarine cable landing licensee.
    • Further, the FCC proposed to adopt this presumption with respect to any entity and its current and future affiliates and subsidiaries whose application is or was previously denied or whose authorization or license is or was previously revoked and/or terminated on national security or law enforcement grounds.
    • The FCC would seek comment on whether to lower the current 10% ownership reporting threshold to five percent (5%) and propose to require submarine cable applicants to
      • (1) provide detailed information concerning the submarine cable infrastructure and
      • (2) include in their applications information about the services they currently offer or plan to offer.
    • Additionally, the FCC would seek comment on whether certain information should be presumptively subject to confidential treatment,” the draft item said
  • Propose new regulatory compliance certifications to protect against national security, law enforcement, and other risks; The FCC proposed that all submarine cable applicants certify:
    • (1) whether they are in compliance with the Commission’s rules and regulations, the Act, and other laws;
    • (2) that they have created, updated, and implemented cybersecurity risk management plans; and
    • (3) as a condition of the potential grant of their application, that the submarine cable system will not use covered equipment or services identified on the Commission’s ‘Covered List’ that the Commission maintains pursuant to the Secure and Trusted Communications Networks Act.
    • The FCC also proposed that all submarine cable landing licensees certify as to whether or not they use, for the relevant submarine cable system, equipment or services identified on the ‘Covered List’ within 60 days of the release of any Report and Order in this proceeding.
    • Additionally, the FCC proposed to amend the Commission's rules by adding a new routine condition and a certification requirement in the proposed periodic reports prohibiting licensees from using, for the relevant submarine cable system, equipment or services identified on the ‘Covered List.’
    • The FCC also seeks comment on whether to require a certification by all applicants/licensees that they have the ability to promptly and effectively interrupt, in whole or in part, traffic to and from the United States on the submarine cable system.
  • Seek comment on steps the Commission can take to protect submarine cable infrastructure, including activities in coordination with our federal partners.
  • Propose and seek comment on updating submarine cable rules and certain targeted requirements to protect submarine cable systems from national security and law enforcement risks. For example, the FCC would seek comment on:
    • (1) whether to require basic information about an applicant’s lessors of submarine cable landing stations and/or data centers housing hardware;
    • (2) ways the Commission can address vulnerabilities associated with logical access to submarine cable systems; and
    • (3) challenges posed by submarine cable licensees’ use of remote service vendors and their services and steps the Commission could take to mitigate those challenges.
    • The FCC proposed, among other things,
      • (1) to require applicants/licensees, with or without reportable foreign ownership, to report whether or not they use and/or will use Managed Network Service Providers (MNSPs) and
      • (2) that any applicant that indicates it uses and/or will use a foreign-owned MNSP will answer the Standard Questions and those applications would be routinely referred to the relevant Executive Branch agencies. Also, we propose to require all applicants to provide a list of the anticipated addresses or physical locations for the Network Operations Center (NOC) on a confidential basis in their applications and in the periodic reporting,
  • Seek comment on streamlining the FCC’s submarine cable review processes. The FCC would seek comment on, for example,
    • (1) ways to modify our streamlining procedures to expedite submarine cable processing while ensuring national security and law enforcement concerns are addressed, and
    • (2) actions or measures the Commission can take to expedite the review and licensing process.
  • Seek comment on improving the quality of the Circuit Capacity data and facilitating the sharing
    of such information with other Federal Agencies. 

Last week, a bipartisan group of eight U.S. senators led by Republican Todd Young and Democrat Chris Murphy called on President Joe Biden’s administration to undertake “a review of existing vulnerabilities to global undersea cable infrastructure, including the threat of sabotage by Russia as well as the growing role of the People’s Republic of China in cable laying and repair.”

The United States for years expressed concerns about China’s role in handling network traffic and potential for espionage.

The senators said ensuring internet traffic security must be a national priority and raised a number of questions including what is the “administration’s overall strategy to guarantee the security of America’s undersea infrastructure and to promote the security of that of our allies and partners?”

Since 2020, U.S. regulators have been instrumental in the cancellation of four cables planned to link the United States with Hong Kong, including PLCN, HKA, BtoBE (CAP-1) and HK-G.

In April, the FCC restored net neutrality rules to regulate Internet service providers, and ordered the U.S. subsidiaries of China Telecom, China Unicom and China Mobile to discontinue broadband internet operations in the United States.

 

Updates:

  1. The FCC voted unanimously (5:0) on 21 November 2024 to begin a comprehensive review of submarine cable licensing rules.
  2. On March 13, 2025, the FCC's Notice of Proposed Rulemaking ( NPRM) was published on the Federal Register, Review of Submarine Cable Landing License Rules and Procedures To Assess Evolving National Security, Law Enforcement, Foreign Policy, and Trade Policy Risks; Schedule of Application Fees. Comments are due on or before April 14, 2025; and reply comments are due on or before May 12, 2025. Written comments on the Paperwork Reduction Act proposed information collection requirements must be submitted by the public, Office of Management and Budget (OMB), and other interested parties on or before May 12, 2025.